Rose Hydrating Facial Toner,
Line by Line

Five things go into this bottle. On the label they become thirteen names, five of which look alarming and are not. Here is every one, in the order it is blended.

·  ·  ·

Most brands publish an ingredient list because the law requires it, and then hope you do not read it. We are going to do the opposite: read it to you, line by line, and say what every name is doing there. This is the first of a recurring series, and we are starting with the toner because it is the simplest formula we make — which makes it the honest place to begin.

Here is the whole thing, in the order it is blended:

That is it. No fragrance added, no colourant, no alcohol. The reason the label shows thirteen names instead of six is that three of these ingredients are legally required to be broken into their parts — and that is where the real education is.

1 · Rosa Damascena Flower Hydrosol the base

The largest single ingredient is not water — it is rose. Specifically the hydrosol: the aromatic water that comes off a rose distillation in Bulgaria. When damask roses are steam-distilled to make rose otto, two things separate — the tiny amount of essential oil, and the far larger volume of fragrant water it distilled through. That water is the hydrosol, and it is what most of this toner is made of.

So let us be precise, because the word “rose” is used loosely everywhere. This toner is built on rose hydrosol, not on rose otto. The otto — the costly oil — is present only in the trace amount the hydrosol naturally carries, which is why you will see the rose’s natural aromatic compounds appear at the very end of the label. We would rather tell you that plainly than let the word “rose otto” do work it has not earned. The hydrosol is the honest hero here, and it is a lovely material in its own right.

2 · Mineral Water, Australia the balance

The remaining third is mineral water, sourced in Australia, where the toner is made. There is nothing exotic to claim about water and we are not going to invent any. Its job is to bring the formula to volume and to carry everything else. We name its origin only because we can, and because a product that says “made in Australia” should be able to say what the Australian part is.

3 · Green Tea Leaf Extract antioxidant

Camellia sinensis — green tea — carried in glycerin. This is the ingredient that also explains a name further up the label: Glycerol (Glycerin). The green tea extract arrives dissolved in glycerin, so the glycerin is declared separately, which is why the label appears to contain an ingredient the recipe does not list on its own line. Green tea contributes antioxidant polyphenols; the glycerin is a second, mild humectant. Two useful things from one addition.

4 · Sodium PCA moisture-binding

Sodium PCA is part of what your own skin uses to stay hydrated — it belongs to the group of compounds skin scientists call the natural moisturising factor. It is a supporting note here, not a headline, and that is the correct role for it. We name it plainly so you can see we are not implying a “clinical” level of anything.

5 · Plantaserv C — the preservative, named protection

Here is the ingredient natural brands most often hide, so we will do the reverse. Plantaserv C is a preservative, and on the label it appears as its two working parts: Sodium Levulinate and Sodium Anisate, both derived from botanical sources. Alongside them sits Citric Acid, which fine-tunes the pH so the whole thing stays in skin’s comfortable range.

A water-based product without a preservative is not “more natural” — it is a place for bacteria to grow. We would rather use a botanically-derived preservative system, tell you exactly what it is and how much, and let you decide, than sell you an unpreserved rose water with a short and dangerous shelf life.

The five names that scare people the allergen line

At the end of the label you will find: Citronellol, Geraniol, Farnesol, Linalool, Eugenol. They read like a warning. They are the opposite of a warning — they are proof there is real rose in the bottle.

These five are aromatic compounds that occur naturally inside rose. We did not add them; they came in with the rose, in the trace of rose otto the hydrosol carries. European labelling law requires that they be declared by name once they cross a very small threshold, so an honest rose product will always list them and a synthetic “rose fragrance” often will not. Their presence is the tell that this is genuinely rose-derived.

Because this is The Full List, here is their scale. Taken together, all five come to less than 0.0500% of the formula — hundredths and thousandths of a percent, not whole numbers. We give the total rather than a line-by-line breakdown, because the underlying figures describe the rose hydrosol as it arrives rather than the finished bottle, and the supplier calls even those typical rather than a guaranteed assay. The total is the honest way to put it.

What does not change is the point: these are hundredths and thousandths of a percent, and they are the rose, not an additive. Small is not the same as none, though. If your skin reacts to rose or to essential-oil aromatics as a category, this product contains them, and you should patch test on the inner arm before using it on your face. We would rather lose the sale than the trust.

What we left out

Just as telling as what is in the bottle is what is not: no synthetic fragrance, no added colour, no alcohol, no silicones, no PEGs. That is not a moral position, it is a formulation one — this toner is meant to be the calm first step, and none of those would have helped it do that job. We will devote a whole article in this series to the things we leave out and why, because “free-from” claims are usually marketing, and we would like ours to be arithmetic.

The label on the back of the bottle prints all of this in six-point type because it has to. We printed it here in full because we want to.

Later in this series: the serum, line by line.

One article, every Tuesday. Ingredients in full, including the ones we left out. Join and take 10% off your first order — code FIRST10.

ENAYIN Natural Skincare · The Rose Record